|
A mainstream conception of the superhero exists within the tales of Spiderman,
Superman, X-Men, and the like. While Hollywood recently has devoted significant
attention to these franchises from both Marvel and D.C., other "heroes"
have emerged through independent film makers and distributors namely Harvey
Pekar (American Splendor), David Dunn (Unbreakable),
and Amelie Poulan (Amelie du Mont Marte). The former enjoys a
moment early in his movie contrasting the aforementioned "true"
superheroes. The middle, of course, functions as Shyamalan's exploration
into the "myth" of the hero, and the final rearticulates the
"hero" of another era, Zorro. What have these three to do with
the resurgence of the hero? Are they riding the wave? Or do these movies
merely coincide with the blockbuster summer movies of the tight clad hero?
I'd like to do a brief exploration in the golden age of comics and radio
in preparation for analysis of these three heroes: Harvey, David, and
Amelie. Transforming Superheroics Through Female Music Style :: Kim Toffoletti Since Angela McRobbie's investigation of the male bias in subcultural
studies in 1980, there has been much feminist analysis of the relationship
between women and popular music. These studies have largely focused on
women's consumption of music as a commodity and the ensuing pleasures
and models of collective and individual identification this offers, or,
have examined the production of music and music style as a site for female
empowerment and resistance to patriarchal structures and institutions.
It is within this context that I approach a recent crop of spunky scream-goddesses:
the sexed-up shock-rocker Peaches, performance-artists turned mainstream
musos Chicks on Speed, and Karen O, the front woman of New York outfit
The Yeah Yeah Yeahs. 'I'm Dying for a Good Slay': Death and the Inversion of Gender Roles in Buffy the Vampire Slayer and The Medea :: Sophia van Gameren This paper will focus on Joss Whedon's Buffy the Vampire Slayer (BtVS) and Euripides's The Medea and how traditional gender roles are re-defined. By looking at the character of Buffy, it will be argued that she usurps a role that traditionally has been occupied by males. In the horror and super-hero genres, a small framed, blonde female would often be the victim of the villain, or be saved by a male superhero. Rather than being the helpless 'damsel in distress', Buffy is the hero, complete with a 'secret' identity. As the Vampire Slayer, it is Buffy's duty to protect and save innocent people from 'the vampires, the demons and the forces of darkness'. Yet, despite this power, Buffy understands that she does not have the right to kill human beings. Although not a super-hero, Euripides's Medea, like Buffy, is no ordinary female and also assumes a traditional masculine role. Medea's a famous sorceress, who murders her children out of a passionate hatred for her husband, Jason, who has rejected her for a younger woman. Although the Athenians believed that women were dangerous and disruptive (especially foreign women like Medea), women were also supposed to be nurturing, compassionate and maternal. By murdering her children, Medea not only exits the feminine sphere, but demonstrates her association with the masculine heroic values of cleverness, honour, status and revenge. Through Medea's self interest, breaking of bonds and use of force and violence, she not only adopts traditional traits of Athenian men, but also exploits them; she fills the masculine role better than most men. Unlike other kin-killers in Greek tragedies, Medea escapes and is not punished for her murders. Death and the punishment of murderers are important themes in BtVS and
Greek tragedies. In BtVS, the conscience of the characters, and the guilt
they feel, is their punishment for taking human lives. In the Buffyverse,
Willow reflects the character of Medea. Willow becomes enraged when her
partner Tara is murdered by Warren and begins a quest of revenge. Unlike
Medea, however, Willow suffers from guilt because she committed murder.
When 'evil' Willow departs, Willow 's conscience punishes her. Although
Willow is not physically punished for committing murder, her conscience
makes it difficult to deal with the knowledge that she took another human
life. In Greek tragedies, characters are often outcast from their cities
after taking a human life, especially a family member's. This can be seen
through characters such as Orestes and Oedipus. Medea also leaves her
home town after murdering her children. Willow is sent away to London
after murdering Warren , however, she is not punished for her misuse of
the black magicks but rather she learns about, and hones, her power. Willow
must rehabilitate herself in London and is punished by her conscience
whilst Medea chooses to leave for Athens and has no remorse for killing
her children, and is not punished by the gods. "I Will Be Silent About His Doom": A Mortal Superhero Among Jealous Gods :: Lina van 't Wout In this paper, I will investigate the portrayal of the ancient Greek superhero Bellerophon in Pindar Olympian 13, a celebratory ode on the Olympic victory of a Corinthian aristocrat in 464 BCE. I will trace the thematics of the story and analyse it with attention to the issue of cultural specificity, suggesting that in spite of the overt differences between Pindar's treatment of this tale and modern superhero sagas, they can be fruitfully compared with regard to their cultural function. Unlike Herakles or Superman, who are born with supernatural powers, Bellerophon is a mere mortal, but nevertheless he has achieved superhuman deeds: he has bridled the divine horse Pegasos, and riding that horse he has slain the Amazons, the monster Chimaira and the Solymoi (Pind. Ol. 13.86-90, Homer Iliad 6.179-86). Across cultures, the tension between the superhuman abilities or achievements of heroes and their (semi-)human status is a theme central to the portrayal of many superheroes. In ancient Greek superheroes that are truly human (i.e. mortal), this tension results in a conflict with religiosity: the gods of the pantheon were jealous gods, and did not tolerate mortals who rose above the mortal standard. Inevitably, Bellerophon becomes over-ambitious and aspires to ride his divine steed to the top of the Olympos, to join the gods: but whereas Pegasos is welcomed in their company, Bellerophon himself is mercilessly punished. This punishment for what the Greeks called hubris, the sin to compare oneself to the gods, is an interesting example of a culturally specific aspect of superheroism. Several other mortal superheroes, like Prometheus and Sisyphos, suffered a comparable fate. Bellerophon's punishment was an essential constituent of his status as a cultural icon in the archaic and classical age (cf. Homer Iliad 6.200-2, Pindar Isthmian 7.44-7). However, I will argue in this paper that Pindar's treatment of the theme of hubris in Olympian 13 serves to circumfere Bellerophon's eventual punishment as the traditional climax of his story, and that the cultural function of the story of Bellerophon as Pindar recounts it is comparable to that of modern superhero sagas. The audience of Olympian 13 were invited to compare the athlete whose victory is being celebrated to a superhero as a person who surpasses what is possible for mortals (Ol.13.30-1: "he has attained what no mortal ever did before") and who uses his excellence to the wellbeing of the community (Ol. 13.86-90, see above). Pindar carefully chooses a perspective on such excellence in which he can in his own words, "be silent about his doom" (Ol. 13.91), without evoking the jealousy of the gods ("may you receive my words without jealousy, father Zeus" Ol. 13.25-6). The implication is that the addressee of the ode, through his athletic victory, has challenged the boundaries of mortality and human ability. In ancient Greece , a tale about a superhero could serve to explore those boundaries - but they were suspiciously guarded by the gods, and only a skilled poet like Pindar could imply that a mortal might break them without evoking their anger. Bio Note :: Lina van 't Wout participates in a research project on citizenship in antiquity at the University of Utrecht, Research Institute for History and Culture: in her PhD project she investigates the meaning and application of ATIMIA (literally loss or lack of honour) as a legal penalty in classical Athens. She has completed her MA in Leiden with a thesis on 'narrative embedding of direct speech in Pindar's epinicia', and is preparing an article on compositional strategy and mythological innovation in Pindar's Pythian 8. Her research interests can be subsumed under the heading 'religion, mentality and politics in archaic and classical Greece'. Email :: Lina.vantWout@let.uu.nl Baroque mutants in the 21st century? Re-thinking genre through the superhero :: Saige Walton As early as the fifties, film theorist André Bazin had coined the term “super-western” to identify the ways in which the Hollywood western had moved beyond its so-called ‘classical’ form to reach a baroque state of play. Is the western (super)hero the real generic precursor to far more elaborately costumed and caped crusaders of justice? The mythology of the superhero certainly recalls the generic inheritance of the Hollywood western: the tortured, outsider mentality of the hero/anti-hero; the overt doubling of superhero/villain; and the maintenance of law and order that harbours a somewhat freakish tendency towards vigilantism. Is the superhero informed by an amalgamation of diverse, generic elements? Does the superhero belong to a genre in its own right? Or might there be larger questions of genre theory that can be brought to light by the figure of the superhero? Infinite variation, mutation and freedom of movement are the true calling cards of the superhero; the baroque play of genre is the superhero’s ultimate costume. Superhero by Numbers :: Lisa Watson + Phil Stocks The superhero is an ingrained part of popular culture that has seen a resurgence in the last decade through the introduction of prominent characters to new audiences through expanded media. Heroes and villains express cultural values regarding what society reveres as admirable and fears as deviant (Klapp 1962) and are a medium for moral education (Grinfeld 1997). Bradford Wright's (2001) book "Comic Book Nation" outlines the evolution of comic book stories and characters mimicking cultural change. Empirically studying the popular appeal of superhero traits, particularly during different eras, can give us insight into our society and trends within its development. But what makes a character popular or prominent? Do readers have preferred super powers? How important is boundless virtue, or courage in the face of insurmountable odds? What of the softer, vulnerable side of a character? Is an Achilles' heel necessary? Moreover, what characteristics are enduring? What was popular during the golden age of comic book heroes may not be desirable in today's society. The aim of this study is to analyse trends in superhero characteristics empirically in order to establish current popular superhero traits. Method: We will construct a model of superhero characteristics encompassing all aspects of the character from fundamental things like superpowers, through motivations, up to sales figures, and so on. We will compile a database of heroes under the model and analyse the data to uncover trends that influence superhero popularity and commercial value. Practical Applications: Apart from shedding light on our cultural values, this information could be applied commercially. One immediate example is to determine the exact characteristics a superhero should possess to optimise commercial viability across various media. This could translate into the creation of the next generation of new superhero, or simply guide the choice of which current hero to next bring to the silver screen. Bio Note :: Lisa Watson is a Postgraduate Fellow of Marketing in the Faculty of Business, Bond University, Queensland. Her research interests include consumer behaviour, relationship marketing, and electronic commerce. Phil Stocks is an Assistant Professor of Computer Science in the Faculty of Information Technology, Bond University, Queensland, and a defender of justice in his spare time. His research interests are in the areas of programming languages, programming language theory, and artificial life. Email :: pstocks@staff.bond.edu.au The Spirits Within: The Shamanic Hero in Final Fantasy :: Lucy Wright Super-muscles and super-powers will only get you so far. When the enemy takes an inexplicably numinous form, you must turn inwards – to the mind, to dreams, to the Spirits Within – in order to find a solution. Scientific shaman-hero Dr Aki Ross uses both her rational mind and her oneiric intuition to save the day, and the planet. My paper will explore how the shamanic figure has been revisioned by this sci-fi anime text, and use a Jungian approach to comment on this reincarnation of the inner journey. Bio Note :: Lucy Wright is a doctoral candidate in the Cinema Studies Program at the University of Melbourne. Her PhD focuses on spiritual ideas in science fiction anime. "Restlessly, violently, headlong, like a river that wants to reach its end..": Nihilism, Reconstruction and the Hero's Journey :: Raymond Younis "I praise, I do not reproach, [nihilism's] arrival. I believe it is one of the greatest crises, a moment of the deepest self-reflection of humanity" - (Nietzsche) Nietzsche foreshadowed a link between the twentieth century and the "advent" of nihilism. In "Will to Power" he wrote: "What I relate is the history of the next two centuries. I describe what is coming, what can no longer come differently: the advent of nihilism. . . . For some time now our whole European culture has been moving as toward a catastrophe, with a tortured tension that is growing from decade to decade: restlessly, violently, headlong, like a river that wants to reach the end.". Heidegger, writing in 1927 (in "The Question of Being"), foreshadowed a time in which nihilism would be humanity's "normal state". In a sense, they were right. There has been much recent interest in such issues. In recent research, "nihilism" has been linked to dialectics (Gillian Rose), the work of Max Stirner (Filadelfo Linares), negative theology and deconstruction (Conor Cunningham), Nietzsche's philosophy (again! Ken Cussen), "Romanticism" and a new understanding of "man and nature, one that puts will in place of reason, and freedom in place of necessity and order" (Michael Allen Gillespie), postmodernism (David Michael Levin), Heidegger's ethics (Karl Löwith), "Gen X" filmmakers such as Soderbergh and Tarantino (Peter Hanson), ethics as a "figure of nihilism" (Alain Badiou), feminist critiques of postmodernism (Susan J. Hekman), "modernity" (Robert B. Pippin), "Narcissism" (Stephen L. Gardner), the "Information Superhighway" (Hubert Dreyfus), aesthetics and institutions (Justin Clemens) . The list is not exhaustive. But there is little or no research on the links between nihilism and the super-heroes of popular culture. This paper will argue that the overcoming (Nietzsche's term is crucial here: "Überwindung") of nihilism is a crucial and integral part of the superhero's journey and ultimately of the superhero's project - one might think of Neo in the Matrix trilogy, Dave in "2001: A Space Odyssey", the crew of the Starship Enterprise (for example in conflict with the Borg in "Star Trek: First Contact"), Daredevil, Spiderman and Catwoman. The paper will close with some (necessarily brief) reflections on the superhero as the figurative and messianic bearer of a new "mythos" and a new "logos" aimed at the overcoming of (postmodernist?) aporetics and heterology; a new "mythos" with an overtly reconstructionist discursive and ideological thrust directed against the advent of an age characterised by tension, uncertainty, aporia, deconstruction, fragmentation, disorder, estrangement, bewilderment, panic and the encounter with the Absurd. It will also be argued that this "mythos" in itself deserves very close scrutiny. Bio Note :: Ray Younis was educated at
Sydney and Oxford and is particularly interested in the relationship between
philosophy (particularly the metaphysics and ethics of Nietzsche and Heidegger
and the epistemology of Wittgenstein and Derrida) and cultural studies.
He has co-edited a number of books on religion, myth and cultural studies
and is currently working on a book length study of nihilism, post-modernity
and deconstruction. He co-ordinates the communication, media and cultural
studies programs at CQU (Sydney), teaches applied ethics and cultural
studies and is a consultant in philosophy at the University of Sydney.
He suspects that he was conceived during a late night screening of “The
Wild Bunch”. It's a Jungle In Here - Separating Man from Animal, and Author from Subject, in Grant Morrison's Animal Man :: Steven Zani Grant Morrison was one of a number of authors who participated in the revisionist trend of the 1980's comic genre, taking over the narrative of a 1960's hero from the DC archives, the unimaginative creation "Animal Man," who can duplicate the abilities of nearby animals. Morrison used the character as a spring board for a multiplicity of themes. Besides addressing immediate contemporary political concerns (notably issues of animal rights and ethics within the first few issues) Morrison drafted an Animal Man that very quickly became a meta-textual platform for discussions of identity construction. The paper intends to address the development that Animal Man, and Morrison himself (who eventually includes himself within the narrative) undergoes in issues #1-26 of the book. In these issues, Morrison's authorial run on the title, Animal Man suffers from a number of trials and crises, sometimes with explicit mythological and Christian symbolic parallels, notably the story of Job. While the comic may have begun with a large scale political message on animal rights, the journey ends with Animal Man pursuing a much more intensely personal, or internal search for identity and meaning. Morrison's final arguments are that enduring heroism is a process achieved by constant evaluation of one's self and one's motives, and by constant attention the process involved in creating, literally writing and drawing, one's own identity. The individual battles and trials are less important than the constructive process of creating oneself in relation to memory and text. In the process, Morrison demonstrated that the possibilities allowed by the comics medium were no less than that allowed by any number of other artistic genres. Certainly there is much that is not new in Morrison's Animal Man. Overt political messages have been a part of the comic genre since its World War II propogandistic origins, a trend continued in any number of other clearly political texts well into the contemporary comics era ("Speedy's" heroin addiction in the 1970's Green Lantern & Green Arrow series comes to mind). Nor is there much new in having characters plagued with self-doubt and/or personal problems-Spider-Man's introspective anxiety is an enduring element of his popularity. But Morrison's eventual metatextual approach, which turned Animal Man into a kind of comic book Tristram Shandy with all of its ludicrous comedies and possibilities, reveals that what is at stake in the comic book is nothing less than what is at stake in all artistic representation whatsoever. In short, Animal Man was a text that raised the stakes of the comic undertaking. In shifting the boundaries that separate man from animal, author from text, Morrison helped usher in an era where the lines dividing comics from writing, comics from art, could become similarly blurred, and even erased. Ultimately, I would argue, the genre has never been the same-a change for the better.Bio Note :: Steven Zani is an Assistant Professor of English at Lamar University . Besides his history of work in multiple comic book stores, he has a PhD in Comparative Literature from the State University of New York in Binghamton . Email :: zanisj@HAL.LAMAR.EDU Superheroes, Superegos : icons of war and the war of icons in the fiction of Kazuo Ishiguro :: Pascal Zinck This paper examines the enduring providential intervention of Superheroes in the fiction of Kazuo Ishiguro, drawing on examples from all of his novels to probe linguistic, psychoanalytical, cultural, and historical aspects. In the first part, I study megalomania and hyperbolic discourse, focussing on Ono, the master painter of An Artist of the Floating World; Stevens, the superlative butler of The Remains of the Day; Ryder, the messianic soloist of The Unconsoled and Christopher Banks, the supersleuth out to eliminate arch-criminals - "the Yellow Snake conspiracy" - in When We Were Orphans. It is clear that most of Ishiguro's protagonists believe that they are entrusted with "a sense of mission" and that they are so omnipotent that they can alter the course of history. Secondly, I adopt a psychoanalytical approach and question to what extent Superheroes and kung fu encounters with Supervillains can be attributed to narcissism and the need to escape tyrannical families. War-like role play emulates childhood toy-soldier battles and World-Cup football games (The Unconsoled). Free from the constraints of gravity, time, place, parents and sex, Superheroes have a close affinity with orphans as is demonstrated by Number Nine, Solar Man, Superman in The Unconsoled and by references to Ivanhoe and Frankenstein in When We Were Orphans. The novels' retrofictional as well as regressive discursive strategies deploy a time warp analogous to fairy-tale temporality. Third, I consider a cultural as well as a historical perspective, more particularly the Japanese context. I borrow Winther-Tamaki's concept of "disembodiment" to describe the marshalling of Yamato damashii legendary heroes and folklore rituals into militaristic icons (An Artist of the Floating World). As a Cold War legacy, ethnicity and paranoid nationalism account for the rise and the demise of Superheroes (The Unconsoled). In the fourth part, far from being icons of modernity or cultural emancipation, I explore how Godzilla, Popeye, John Wayne, Gary Cooper, Humphrey Bogart or Clint Eastwood epitomise the shackles of celluloid globalisation (A Pale View of Hills, An Artist of the Floating World, The Unconsoled). As a consequence, major tragic events in history such as the Shoah and the nuclear holocaust are erased from memory or trivialised in cartoon-like slapstick. This is what Kazuo Ishiguro, after a visit to Auschwitz , has termed a "Guy Fawkes sort of way". The proliferation of Superheroes contributes to the dehistoricising process. Bio Note :: I have been a university academic since 1992, specialising in post-modern, post-colonial fiction. I obtained a PhD from the Sorbonne university, with a thesis entitled 'The art of the fugue - alienation in the fiction of Kazuo Ishiguro'. Professional works include commissioning authors and writing a chapter and exhaustive bibliography for a book on The Remains of the Day published in 1999. I have written several articles on Ishiguro, the latest due for publication by Ebc-Montpellier UP, the University of Karlstad and the Sorbonne. Email :: cap.zinck@wanadoo.fr |